Winter browning is most severe on younger trees up to about 25 years old, although some older trees or older stands also have some browning. Trees in plantations and trees on the edges of forest stands are severely affected. It affects the upper parts of the trees while lower portions are often still green.
Symptoms
Winter browning causes the needles on conifer trees to dry out and turn brown. In some species, the needles may appear red, yellow, or grey, or purple in blue spruces. In most cases, the buds are still alive. Damage is more severe on younger, smaller trees, on the south or west side of trees, and edge trees with westerly or southerly exposures.
Cause
During periods of increased sunlight, strong winds, and warm temperatures, conifers lose water from their needles faster than they can replace it. This is common in February and March. Dormant roots and the frozen ground prevent the tree from replacing lost water, causing the needles to dry out and die.
It affects smaller trees more severely
It can affect smaller trees more severely because larger trees have more moisture to replenish the water lost to drying conditions. Smaller trees also have more foliage closer to the ground, where sunlight reflected from snow or ice can increase temperatures and cause increased drying of needles. Foliage below the snowline is protected from the drying conditions, and will survive the event and remain green. If there is no snow, heating of the ground by the sun warms the surrounding air, which in turn warms the parts of the tree closest to the ground, making smaller trees more susceptible to drying.
Needle damage
The damage to needles worsens when warm temperatures and sunlight cause the needles to break dormancy and begin photosynthesis (using energy from the sun to convert water and CO2 into carbohydrates). Active needles lose their cold tolerance and can freeze if cold temperatures return. If one or more thaw/freeze cycles occur after sunlight, strong winds, and warm temperatures, the needles can dry out, freeze, and die.
Spring of 2012
This is likely what occurred in northwestern Ontario in the spring of 2012. Record-breaking high temperatures in March (10 - 22) were followed by an extended period of cold temperatures and winter weather. Cold days were followed by short periods of warm temperatures, setting up a cycle of thawing and freezing of the needles. Initial drying of the needles caused cells to lose moisture, damaging the needle tissues. The needles may have been able to recover from this but thaw/freeze cycles in May caused further damage to the tissues before they could repair themselves from drying. Trees would have appeared healthy in March, but cold weather in May killed the damaged needles, resulting in rapid death and browning.
Impacts
In most cases, the warm weather in March did not last long enough for trees to break bud and start growing and producing new shoots. Buds have likely survived with little damage. Trees may look heavily damaged, but if buds are still alive then the trees can recover from the loss of needles. Existing buds will break dormancy in response to warm spring weather growing into new shoots with a new crop of needles. Ground checks May 10 to 14 in 2012 showed good bud expansion and healthy growth, indicating the trees were recovering. A better growing season (i.e., ample rainfall and moderate temperatures) the following years, provided a better the chance for trees to make a full recovery.
Damaged needles
Damaged needles drop from the trees during the summer, leaving the older sections of the branches bare of needles. Within one to two years, the damage should no longer be visible. It is important to note that dry, flammable needles, are an increased fire hazard.
What you can do
Watering trees with a low spraying sprinkler system is the best way for these browning Conifers to overcome the stress.